Synthetic Shake Roof Replacement Costs: What You Need to Know

Are you considering replacing your cedar shake roof with a synthetic shake? Many Colorado Springs homeowners have been encouraged to replace their cedar shake roof with a synthetic shake roof due to the fire and safety concerns of natural shake roofs. Whether you're on the verge of making a transformative change or simply seeking more information, it’s important to understand the cost implications before diving into your project.

In this blog post, we'll explore the factors influencing the cost of a synthetic shake roof replacement. Several variables must be considered, from the size of your roof to the quality of the materials used.

Additionally, we will explore average cost estimates. Understanding the cost per square foot and the cost of an average-sized home can help you budget effectively. But cost is not the only consideration when replacing your synthetic shake roof. Choosing the right material is crucial. We'll compare the options available, composite shakes and polymer shakes, and discuss their benefits and drawbacks.

Furthermore, we will examine the longevity and maintenance considerations associated with synthetic shake roofs and potential cost savings in the long run. Finally, we will highlight the importance of hiring a professional for your project, exploring their expertise and experience, as well as the warranty and insurance coverage that comes with their services.

The Cost Factors of a Synthetic Shake Roof Replacement

Cedar shake roofs enjoy popularity in our mountain region, cherished for their aesthetics and natural appearance. However, escalating safety concerns are prompting many homeowners to consider transitioning to a synthetic alternative. But what's the financial aspect of replacing your cedar shake roof with a synthetic version? Let's explore the factors that play a role in determining the cost of a synthetic shake roof replacement.

Example: Cedar Shake roof

Roof Size and Complexity

When it comes to the cost of replacing your roof with a synthetic shake roof, one of the factors that can influence it is the size and complexity of your roof.

The square footage of your roof plays a significant role in determining the cost, as larger roofs require more materials and labor. Additionally, the roof pitch, or the steepness of your roof, can also impact the cost. Steeper roofs require more safety measures and may require additional equipment, which can increase the overall cost.

Another factor to consider is the architectural features of your roof, such as dormers, skylights, or multiple roof levels. These features can complicate the installation process, leading to higher costs. It is important to consider these factors when budgeting for your synthetic shake roof replacement to ensure an accurate estimate.

Example: Large, complex Cedar Shake roof with multiple facets

Choice of Material

When it comes to choosing the right synthetic shake material for your roof replacement, there are a couple of factors to consider.

• Manufacturer
• Product Line

One important factor is the choice of manufacturer. Choosing a reputable manufacturer known for producing high-quality synthetic shake materials is paramount. A couple that we've installed and have first-hand experience with are DaVinci Roofscapes and F-Wave Roofing. Be sure to consult your roofing contractor when you are researching and comparing different manufacturers, as their expertise can help you find the best option that suits your needs and budget.

Example: DaVinci Synthetic Shake roof

Example: F-Wave Synthetic Shake roof

Additionally, you'll need to consider the product line of the synthetic shake materials. Depending on the manufacturer you select, there may be different width profiles to choose from, offering a different aesthetic look. The product line you decide on can impact the overall cost of the roof replacement, as some options may be more expensive than others.

Average Costs of Synthetic Shake Roof Replacements

While the cost of a synthetic shake roof replacement can vary, having a general idea of the average costs associated with this project is helpful.

Cost per Square Foot

Typically, your roof size, complexity, and the following three variables will significantly impact your roof replacement cost per square foot.

• Manufacturers - Different manufacturers offer materials at different price points.
• Width Options (if applicable) - Synthetic shake roof tiles may come in various width options, depending on the manufacturer.

Additional Costs to Consider

• Underlayment - The quality of underlayment impacts the overall cost of replacement.
• Accessory Items - Valley metal and flashings contribute to the overall expense. Opting for copper flashings, while more expensive than standard metal flashings, is a choice some homeowners make to enhance the aesthetic appeal of their new roof.
• Snow Guards - Snow management systems are crucial for synthetic shake roofs that shed snow onto decks, driveways, or other entry points. The potential for snow and ice to avalanche off a sloped roof poses a significant hazard to both people and the property below. The amount of snow retention needed could affect the cost of your project.

Example: Snow guards

While these play a role in the cost per square foot, you can expect synthetic shake roofs to cost between $18.00 and $22.00 per square foot.

Choosing the Right Material for Your Synthetic Shake Roof Replacement

When replacing your synthetic shake roof, selecting the right material is crucial. Discover the different options available and their pros and cons to make an informed decision.

Synthetic Shake Roof Manufacturers and Materials

When it comes to choosing the right material for your synthetic shake roof replacement, you have a couple of options to consider. The manufacturer and the type of material. Two popular brands are DaVinci, which specializes in composite shakes, and F-Wave, which features polymer shakes. 

DaVinci's composite shakes are modeled from actual hand-split shake for natural, non-repeating beauty and decades of enduring harsh environments. These state-of-the-art tiles are made of virgin resins fortified with advanced UV stabilizers, meaning the color you pick is the color you keep. Their unique composite construction also outperforms natural cedar shake with a Class A Fire Rating, Class 4 Impact Rating, and a 110 mph Wind Rating.

Longevity and Maintenance Considerations

When it comes to the lifespan of different synthetic shake roof materials, homeowners can expect a durable and long-lasting roofing solution. On average, synthetic shake roofs can last more than 30 years, depending on the specific material and manufacturer. This lifespan surpasses that of traditional cedar shake roofs, which typically last around 20 to 25 years.

The required maintenance for synthetic shake roofs is also minimal compared to their natural counterparts. Regular inspections to check for any damaged or missing tiles and occasional cleaning to remove debris are usually sufficient. Additionally, synthetic shake roofs are resistant to issues such as rot, insect infestation, and warping, further reducing the need for extensive maintenance.

In terms of cost savings in the long run, synthetic shake roofs may be more expensive upfront than cedar shake roofs. However, their longer lifespan and lower maintenance requirements can provide significant cost savings over time. It is important to consult with a professional roofing contractor to get an accurate estimate of the cost and to ensure proper installation for optimal performance and longevity.

Finding the Right Contractor for Your Metal Roof Replacement

Selecting a reputable contractor is vital for a successful and cost-effective synthetic shake roof replacement. Verify that the contractor you hire has the necessary experience and expertise to install synthetic shake roofs. The installation differs from asphalt shingle roofs, and an inexperienced contractor may not be familiar with manufacturer installation standards, which could void your warranty.

Holladay Grace proudly serves the Greater Pikes Peak Region

Financing Options for Your Synthetic Shake Roof Replacement

Conclusion

In conclusion, replacing a cedar shake roof with a synthetic shake roof is a decision many Colorado Springs homeowners are considering due to insurance coverage and fire concerns.

The cost of a synthetic shake roof replacement depends on factors such as the size and complexity of the roof, the choice of materials, and additional costs like underlayment and snow guards. If cost is a concern, there are financing options available to make the investment more manageable.

It is important to choose a reputable manufacturer and material that suits your budget and aesthetic preferences. Synthetic shake roofs have a longer lifespan and require less maintenance compared to natural shake roofs, providing cost savings in the long run.

Hiring a professional contractor is crucial for a successful installation. Researching, comparing proposals, and checking references can help you find the right contractor.

Overall, replacing a cedar shake roof with a synthetic shake roof is a valuable investment in terms of safety, longevity, and cost savings. For more information and guidance, consult with a professional roofing contractor.